I’m Lennie Harris, managing director of HCA Consultancy. As a forensic accountant, I am frequently approached by prisoners who have been served Proceeds of Crime Orders. It’s fair to say that if someone has benefited financially from crime the proceeds should be used to repay the victims. The problem is that the penalties imposed by the courts are often arbitrary and don’t reflect the actual gain.
Some might say that if the prisoner is guilty who cares, but they fail to recognise the adverse effects of additional and unnecessary financial burdens placed on the prisoners, who are already serving his sentence, and their spouses and families. In short, the POCA should reflect the true value of the crime but if it’s excessive I believe it can only encourage reoffending.
Let me explain:
Proceeds of Crime Orders (POCAs) are legal instruments used by courts to confiscate assets derived from criminal activities. While these orders are meant to deter criminal behaviour and disrupt the financial infrastructure of crime, they can also have complex and unintended consequences. Specifically, excessive POCAs, combined with the financial difficulties often faced by former prisoners, can inadvertently increase the likelihood of reoffending. This podcast explores how arbitrary and excessive POCAs impact ex-offenders, the role of forensic accountants in challenging these orders, and how financial hardships contribute to recidivism.
Understanding Proceeds of Crime Orders (POCAs)
Proceeds of Crime Orders are designed to strip criminals of their financial gains and resources used to facilitate crime. They are typically applied to cases involving fraud, drug trafficking, money laundering, and other serious offenses. The court assesses the value of the defendant's assets and determines the amount to be confiscated based on the benefit gained from their criminal activities. However, POCAs can sometimes be based on arbitrary or inflated figures, which can lead to disproportionate and excessive financial penalties.
Effects of Excessive POCAs
Increased Financial Hardship:
Excessive POCAs can leave ex-offenders with insurmountable debt and limited financial resources, exacerbating the already challenging economic circumstances faced by many after release. When the amount seized far exceeds the actual criminal gain, it can leave individuals unable to meet basic needs such as housing, food, and healthcare.
Barriers to Reintegration:
Financial stability is a critical component of successful reintegration into society. Excessive POCAs can undermine this stability, making it difficult for ex-offenders to secure housing or employment. Without a stable income or support network, the likelihood of reoffending increases as individuals struggle to find legal means to survive.
Psychological Impact:
The stress and anxiety caused by excessive financial penalties can lead to mental health issues such as depression, anxiety, and a sense of hopelessness. These psychological burdens can diminish motivation to comply with legal obligations and contribute to a negative self-identity, which in turn can foster a return to criminal behaviour.
Perpetuation of Criminal Networks:
In some cases, the financial pressure from excessive POCAs can push ex-offenders back into criminal networks as a means of coping with their financial situation. This not only increases the risk of reoffending but also reinforces the cycle of crime within communities.
Role of Forensic Accountants in Challenging Arbitrary POCAs
Experienced forensic accountants play a crucial role in challenging arbitrary and excessive POCAs. They help ensure that the financial assessments used to determine the amount to be confiscated are accurate and fair. Forensic accountants achieve this by:
Analysing Financial Records:
They meticulously review the defendant's financial records to identify any discrepancies or inaccuracies in the prosecution's assessment of criminal proceeds. By providing a detailed and accurate analysis, they can challenge inflated figures and help courts make more informed decisions.
Valuing Assets:
Forensic accountants assess the true value of the defendant's assets, considering factors such as depreciation, market conditions, and legitimate sources of income. This comprehensive evaluation can prevent the court from overestimating the defendant's financial gains from criminal activities.
Identifying Legal Income:
By distinguishing between legal and illegal income, forensic accountants can help reduce the amount subject to confiscation under POCAs. This distinction is critical in cases where the defendant's assets include a mix of legal and illegal earnings.
Providing Expert Testimony:
In court, forensic accountants provide expert testimony to support their findings and challenge the prosecution's claims. Their expertise can influence the court's decision and lead to more equitable outcomes for defendants.
Financial Problems and Recidivism
Financial problems are a significant factor contributing to recidivism among former prisoners. The challenges faced by ex-offenders include:
Limited Employment Opportunities:
Individuals with a criminal record often face discrimination in the job market, making it difficult to secure stable and well-paying employment. This lack of opportunity can lead to financial instability and increase the risk of reoffending.
Debt and Financial Obligations:
Many ex-offenders leave prison with substantial debt, including legal fees, fines, and restitution payments. These financial obligations, coupled with limited income, can create a cycle of poverty that is hard to escape.
Lack of Access to Financial Services:
Ex-offenders may find it challenging to access traditional financial services such as banking, credit, and loans. Without access to these services, they may turn to high-interest loans or other predatory financial products, exacerbating their financial difficulties.
Inadequate Financial Literacy:
A lack of financial literacy can prevent ex-offenders from managing their money effectively, making it difficult to budget, save, and invest. This can lead to poor financial decisions and increase the risk of reoffending as individuals struggle to make ends meet.
Strategies to Address Financial Problems and Reduce Recidivism
To mitigate the impact of financial problems on recidivism, several strategies can be implemented:
Fair and Proportionate POCAs:
Ensuring that POCAs are based on accurate and fair assessments of criminal proceeds can prevent excessive financial penalties and reduce the likelihood of reoffending. This requires collaboration between the legal system and forensic accountants to evaluate the defendant's assets accurately.
Employment and Training Programs:
Providing ex-offenders with access to employment and vocational training programs can improve their job prospects and financial stability. These programs should focus on developing skills that are in demand in the job market and offer support in job placement and retention.
Debt Management and Financial Counselling:
Offering debt management and financial counselling services to ex-offenders can help them navigate their financial obligations and develop effective budgeting and saving strategies. This support can reduce financial stress and promote economic self-sufficiency.
Access to Financial Services:
Expanding access to traditional financial services for ex-offenders can help them avoid predatory lending practices and build a solid financial foundation. This may include partnerships with banks and credit unions to offer tailored products and services to this population.
Conclusion
Proceeds of Crime Orders and financial problems significantly impact the likelihood of prisoners reoffending. While POCAs are intended to deter criminal behaviour, excessive and arbitrary orders can increase financial hardship and push ex-offenders back into criminal activities. Addressing these challenges requires a comprehensive approach that includes accurate financial assessments, employment opportunities, debt management support, and access to financial services. By implementing these strategies, the criminal justice system can help break the cycle of recidivism and promote successful reintegration into society. My thoughts are in line with most prisoner rehabilitation charities who define financial hardship and instability among the main reasons for re-offending.
The experience has demonstrated to me that the prisoner under pressure is confused. The whole POCA process is confusing and it can just be the beginning of a downhill cycle. There is so much more that can be done. At HCA we recognise the problems and can provide prisoners with many solutions ranging from opening bank accounts, power of attorney, realising assets from property and assets, and much more. My message is don’t suffer in silence. If you’re a prisoner or a family member under financial pressure just talk to me. It won’t take much of your time but it could make a big difference to your life.
Comentários