top of page

THE ROLE OF FORENSIC ACCOUNTANTS IN LEGAL APPEALS: A CASE STUDY OF POTENTIAL MISCARRIAGE OF JUSTICE

martinnewmanpr

The Role of Forensic Accountants in Legal Appeals: A Case Study of Potential Miscarriage of Justice

As a forensic accountant, I am often called upon to provide objective, data-driven financial analysis in legal cases, working with legal teams to ensure that all aspects of a case, particularly financial ones, are thoroughly examined. While my role is inherently analytical, I recognize the importance of remaining non-judgmental, especially when working with individuals who have been convicted and are serving prison sentences. Criminal convictions, particularly lengthy ones, carry a profound impact not only on the individual but also on their families. Financial hardship is often a significant consequence, with many families facing severe economic strain due to the loss of income and other financial disruptions.

One critical issue that arises in these cases is the use of Proceeds of Crime Orders (POCA), which are often imposed arbitrarily by the courts. These orders, designed to strip criminals of the monetary gains from their crimes, sometimes bear little relationship to the actual financial benefit derived from the criminal activity. As a result, individuals may face double punishment—once for their crime and again through financial penalties that may not be proportionate to their actual gain.

In my work, I frequently assist prisoners and their legal teams in ascertaining accurate financial information, which can then be presented to the court in order to rectify any disproportionate or incorrect financial demands. A thorough and impartial forensic investigation can reveal discrepancies and help ensure that the sentencing reflects a fair assessment of the financial aspects of the crime.

Assisting with Alleged Miscarriages of Justice

In some cases, I am also called upon to assist legal teams in supporting applications to the Criminal Cases Review Commission (CCRC) when there are concerns about a potential miscarriage of justice. Recently, I was instructed by a law firm to prepare a report for a client involved in an appeal against a conviction related to people trafficking and modern slavery. The client, originally sentenced to 14 years in prison, had seen their sentence increased to 18 years following an appeal by the Attorney General.

The case was complex. The accused, who had properties in multiple countries and bank accounts both in the UK and abroad, faced allegations of hidden assets. While the defendant had disclosed the existence of overseas accounts, no investigation or proper assessment had been made by the court. This omission resulted in the judge assuming the presence of hidden assets and passing a confiscation order based on this assumption. This is where forensic accountants can play a critical role, as they are trained to identify and evaluate financial data that may have been overlooked or misinterpreted.

In this particular case, I approached the situation by conducting a review of the work already carried out, providing a detailed commentary and analysis of the available evidence. My immediate concern was with the amount of the confiscation order £183,306 imposed by the presiding judge. There were several factors that raised red flags, particularly around the client’s representation and the adequacy of the legal process.

 

Concerns with Legal Representation and Evidence

The client had been provided with legal representation by the National Crime Agency, but her solicitor had been absent from the three-day hearing, and the replacement lawyer seemed unfamiliar with the details of the case. In addition, the client was never questioned regarding her overseas properties, despite her disclosure of their existence. This omission by her solicitor meant that the case was not properly prepared, and key facts were not brought before the court.

Moreover, the trial judge had been given insufficient information about the overseas property, which was a critical piece of evidence. The property, which had been raided by authorities under the assumption that it was being used for modern slavery, had no direct evidence linking it to the crime. No people were found, and important documents were seized under questionable circumstances. Additionally, statements from workers were not presented to the jury, and the entry into the property had been made without a warrant.

As a forensic accountant, my expertise would have included ensuring that all relevant financial documents and evidence related to the property were presented to the court. In my opinion, the absence of this evidence was a significant factor in the miscarriage of justice.

Issues with Property Valuation and Ownership

The property in question raised additional concerns. The court had made assumptions regarding its ownership and value, despite the fact that the client was not the legal owner. The valuation of the property was based on incomplete and assumed data, with no structural tests conducted and no clear documentation supporting the market value. The surveyor’s report was based on estimated measurements rather than actual inspections, which should never be the case in legal proceedings.

Furthermore, the client’s uncle was the true owner of the property but was never interviewed or called as a witness. The judge made the assumption that the client owned the entire piece of of land, disregarding important documents and facts that were available to the Crown. These critical oversights could have been addressed had the appropriate financial and legal reviews been conducted by an experienced forensic accountant.

The Need for Comprehensive Financial Review

The concerns surrounding the property valuation and ownership are just a small part of a much larger issue. Throughout the case, there were numerous assumptions made about payments to victims, the independence of financial investigators, and the validity of the financial records presented in court. In my opinion, a more thorough investigation into the financial aspects of the case could have led to a different outcome.

For example, the client had worked in the UK as a midwife, with earnings subject to PAYE taxation. These records were not produced at trial, which is a critical oversight. Similarly, claims about the client’s involvement in running businesses in Germany were not supported by sufficient financial documentation. These records should have been obtained and reviewed as part of a full financial investigation.

 

Conclusion: The Importance of Forensic Accounting in Legal Cases

In this case, it is clear to me that a miscarriage of justice may have occurred. The lack of thorough financial investigation, the assumptions made regarding property ownership and values, and the failure to consider important evidence all point to a flawed legal process.

This case highlights the crucial role forensic accountants can play in legal proceedings. Had I been involved at the outset, many of these issues could have been identified and addressed much earlier. It is essential that solicitors fully understand the value of forensic accounting in complex legal cases, especially when financial evidence is central to the outcome.

In conclusion, my report to the current legal team aims to address the issues in the case, providing a detailed review of the assumptions and financial figures that were presented to the court. The goal is to assist in making a compelling argument for the Criminal Cases Review Commission to consider this case as a potential miscarriage of justice, and if successful, to support further investigations that could aid the court in reaching a fair decision.

2 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page